Questions? (877) 643-7244
FutureNow Post
Thursday, Mar. 22, 2007 at 4:07 am

What Price Will You Pay for Action at Google?

By Bryan Eisenberg
March 22nd, 2007

Will it Pop?Barry Schwartz reports that Google has just launched Pay-Per-Action ads.

According to Schwartz:

Google Pay Per Action will allow advertisers to create ads that cost only when a desired action is triggered. The advertiser sets the price per action; for example, an advertiser can decide to pay $5 per lead acquisition, as opposed to paying per click or per impression.

The New York Times ran an article on the subject entitled “Google Tests an Ad Idea: Pay Only for Results.”

Says Times reporter Miguel Helft:

Many advertisers find cost-per-action appealing, as it greatly reduces their risk, since they are not charged for ads that are ineffective. The model has long been used online by “affiliate marketing” companies like ValueClick, which have created networks of hundreds or thousands of Web sites that display small ads for e-commerce sites. The publishers are paid when they refer a user who makes a purchase.

But many other companies are using cost-per-action ads in different ways. They include the search-engine start-up Snap, which displays cost-per-action ads next to search results, and Turn, a network that matches advertisers and publishers interested in cost-per-action ads.

We think it is a model that all the large players in search will be embracing over time,” said Tom McGovern, the chief executive of Snap.

For the time being, Google is not putting cost-per-action ads next to search results, limiting them to publishers’ Web sites and essentially creating its own affiliate marketing network. Industry insiders said Google’s entry into the market was likely to accelerate its growth.

Insightful as always, Scott Karp asks on his Publishing 2.0 blog “Can Google Transform The Entire Web Into A Direct Marketing Machine?

Google’s contextual advertising revolution has already transformed the structure of the web, leading to the creation of millions of web pages with no other real purpose than to serve AdSense ads. The content on these pages is purely a vehicle for advertising — the traditional Chinese Wall between editorial and advertising has been obliterated. And it has force many publishers who follow a more traditional editorial path to start poking holes in the wall. Content has always been a marketing vehicle, but never at such a granular, easy-to-manipulate level.

With its CPA program,” Karp continues, “Google will drive this phenomenon to the next level. With cost-per-click ads, spammers create bogus pages where confused consumers click on ads in an effort to escape. But with CPA ads, clicking is not enough. The game is now to manipulate consumers not only to click, but to take some further action. And I don’t use the word “manipulate” arbitrarily. This is about turning the web into one big pile of junk mail, aimed at getting you to sign up, buy, or commit to something that you hadn’t necessarily wanted.

Google must know that most CPA (Cost Per Acquisition) deals waste publishers’ time because they aren’t very often effective and haven’t actually been optimized. Traditionally, instead of offering an optimized offer, people mash-up an ad and a landing page, then try to convince publishers to risk the deal. Publishers pay with their time and inventory. Since Google’s CPA deal is automated, it won’t waste time but could waste inventory.

I’ve always found that it’s more effective for an advertiser to spend the time developing an optimized offer–often using cheap CPA or very cheap CPM inventory–to maximize conversions. Once you establish your baseline cost-per-action, go ahead and buy CPM inventory at about 10-20% the cost of baseline. However, the optimization cycle must come first! Google offering CPA advertising will most likely bring around a new batch of lame and lazy advertisers, the mediocre ones that currently are avoiding their own risk by not even paying for traffic on a CPM basis today.

Will Google enforce a minimum conversion expectation? And, if so, how? What will the minimum be?

Add Your Comments

Comments (6)

  1. I’m more interested in how Google will be able to prove that the action has taken place. What’s to stop anyone removing the code that tells Google an action has taken place, to save themselves money?

  2. It’s called fraud. I’m sure some will try it. I’m curious what Google is doing to prevent it.

  3. In the Google Website Optimizer beta tests they make sure you validate all your tags. Could you imagine Google validating them then running a spider to make sure the tags stay there? Hmmmmm.

  4. I reall doubt that a lot of people will mess with Google by defrauding their publishers. It’s just not a good idea to do that with someone who is awash in cash.

    But in any case, the important thing is the quality of the advertisers. Smart publishers will ignore the riff-raff offers where all the risk lies, and will look for deep pocketed brand name players who are using this model.

    There will be some gold for the publisher who knows how to work the affiliate model. With a quality advertiser, you should make money, because you are taking more of the risk. And the quality advertiser will be glad to pay you more money in this model, because the model screens out the fraudulent publishers.

    I have been involved in publishing sites that used primarily CPA advertising for the past 4 years, and it has worked very well for us.

  5. You’d hope so, Bryan. But, as an example – when someone contacts us on one of our sites, the page doesn’t refresh, as it sends an AJAX request. So, they wouldn’t be able to send spiders to view if it’s there or not, without attempting to get in touch on a daily basis.

  6. Fraud for sure :)

Add Your Comments


Print this Article

Bryan Eisenberg, founder of FutureNow, is a professional marketing speaker and the co-author of New York Times and Wall Street Journal bestselling books Call to Action and Waiting For Your Cat to Bark and Always Be Testing. You can friend him on Facebook or Twitter.

More articles from Bryan Eisenberg

Marketing Optimization Blog
FREE Newsletter Sign-Up
send it once every: